What is a true Utopia?

This week explores the aspects of a Utopia, both through the words of Sir Thomas More and through class discussion.  While reading I found it interesting how structured their schedules were and how they all had a job that they did for the same amount of time each day.  It makes me wondered if this supposed "utopia" could be so structured that it is almost boring.  What in the world is perfect about that?  Their families requirements seem a bit on the extreme side, but at least there is less chance for poverty since everyone is allowed to just take what they need.  I also liked how they described the hospital because it actually sounded like it might not be drudgery to go there!  In the area of dress, I wonder what the distinguishing factor is between those that are married and those that are unmarried.  Also, it is quite fascinating that jewels are only for the children.  Quite opposite of our society where children are not even allowed to touch expensive things!  Isn't it fun though to read about someone else's "utopia" and compare it to what you may imagine?

Then to the class discussion, which went in some interesting directions.  The main part of class was spent discussing whether the individual or society is responsible for a criminal.  I believe that it is society's fault because the environment and things around a person are what shapes his/her beliefs and morals.  In other words I agreed with the statement that society creates conditions to create criminals.  Personally I find this really sad and wonder if there is even a way to stop this from happening any further.  Then we discussed when capital punishment should be used.  I found that I don't really have a strong opinion on this issue.  Maybe it is based upon the fact that I just don't feel right about killing at all.  To end on an interesting note, it's mindboggling to analyze the statement that Dr. Tucker made about pleasure causing pain for someone else....is this absolutely true in every situation?  I guess it probably is, even if it is just a small element....this may in fact make me a bit more wary about everything I choose to do.

Now I will soon be off to Europe...possibly in some of the same areas these Renaissance artists and writers visited...stepping back in time...for a break...possibly a taste of a utopia...or does everyone have a place in their lives that is considered their "utopia?"